← All posts

How Much Do Roofing Supplement Companies Charge?

November 17, 2026 · Insurance · 6 min read ·

Short answer: published roofing supplement fees we checked on November 17, 2026 run from 8% to 15% of the approved increase, or a flat $150 per supplement. Estimate on Demand charges 10% of the increase with no minimum (8% on its $2,999-a-month Grow plan), The Estimate Company lists 15% as its standard fee, and American Roof Supplements lists $150 per supplement.

A supplement is the request you send an insurance carrier for items its first estimate left out: decking, drip edge, starter, flashing, code items, extra waste. Many roofing companies pay an outside supplement company to write them. This post lists what those companies actually publish, shows when a flat fee beats a percentage, and covers when it makes more sense to keep supplements in-house. If you write your own, start with our guide to writing a roofing supplement that gets approved.

What do roofing supplement companies charge in 2026?

Most charge a percentage of the amount the carrier adds to the claim, and a smaller group charges a flat fee per supplement. Here is what three companies publish on their own sites:

Company and planFee modelPublished priceSource, date checked
Estimate on Demand (EOD), Build planPercentage10% of the increased amount, no minimum; no fee if there is no increase; billed net 28 after the job closesEOD supplement pricing page, November 17, 2026
Estimate on Demand (EOD), Grow planPercentage plus monthly fee8% of the increase plus $2,999 a month, billed quarterlyEOD supplement pricing page, November 17, 2026
The Estimate Company, standardPercentage15% standard; 12% on its Desk Retainer and 10% on its Priority DeskThe Estimate Company resources page, November 17, 2026
American Roof SupplementsFlat fee$150 per supplement, $50 per estimate; first estimate or supplement free for new clientsAmerican Roof Supplements terms and conditions, November 17, 2026

The Estimate Company also states that the industry range is typically 10% to 20%, with 15% most common, and that flat-fee companies typically charge $150 to $500 per supplement. Many supplement companies publish no price at all; if a company will only quote on a call, get the quote in writing before you send a file.

Is a flat fee or a percentage fee cheaper?

A $150 flat fee is cheaper than a 10% fee once the approved increase passes $1,500, and cheaper than a 15% fee once it passes $1,000. Below those amounts the percentage costs less. Using the published rates above:

Approved increase10% fee15% fee$150 flat fee
$800$80$120$150
$1,500$150$225$150
$3,000$300$450$150
$6,000$600$900$150

The percentage model has one real advantage: the company only earns when the carrier pays, and EOD states plainly that no increase means no fee. Pull the approved increases from your last ten insurance jobs and price both models on that average, not on your biggest win.

When does a monthly plan beat paying per supplement?

Only at high volume. EOD's Grow plan saves 2 percentage points (8% instead of 10%) but costs $2,999 a month, so it breaks even at about $149,950 in approved increases every month ($2,999 divided by 0.02). Apply the same test to any retainer: divide the monthly cost by the points it saves.

Should you hire a supplement company or supplement in-house?

Outsource when your insurance volume is spiky, such as after a hail event, or when nobody on staff writes Xactimate; keep it in-house when you run steady claim volume and already have an estimator. Software sits in between. SupplementSnap listed plans at $99 a month (1 user), $199 (3 users) and $299 (5 users) on November 17, 2026; it helps crews photograph findings during tear-off and drafts supplement language, and it states it is not connected to insurers. OvrScope said its plans start at $199 a month with no per-user fees.

The math: four supplements a month at a $3,000 average increase cost $1,200 at 10%. Software costs far less, but your estimator now spends the hours on writing, submitting and chasing the adjuster.

What should you send a supplement company?

Send the carrier's full estimate, an accurate roof measurement, and dated photos of every item you are asking for. A complete file usually includes:

RoofMetric includes satellite roof measurement on its Solo plan at $29 a month, along with CRM, branded PDF estimates and storm tracking, per our pricing page, so your measurement is ready before the file goes out.

What should you check before signing with a supplement company?

Check what the percentage is calculated on, when the fee is due, and whether anything is owed on a denial. Also ask whether there is a minimum and who talks to the adjuster. Rules on who may negotiate a claim differ by state, so confirm the arrangement fits yours.

Frequently asked questions

How much do roofing supplement companies charge?

Published fees we checked on November 17, 2026 run from 8% to 15% of the approved increase, or a flat fee. Estimate on Demand charges 10% of the increase with no minimum (8% on its $2,999-a-month Grow plan), The Estimate Company lists a 15% standard fee, and American Roof Supplements lists $150 per supplement. Many supplement companies do not publish prices at all, so ask for a written quote.

Is a flat fee or a percentage cheaper for a roof supplement?

It depends on the size of the approved increase. A $150 flat fee costs the same as a 10% fee on a $1,500 increase and the same as a 15% fee on a $1,000 increase. Above those amounts the flat fee is cheaper; below them the percentage is cheaper. Run the math on your average approved increase from the last ten insurance jobs, not on your best one.

Do supplement companies charge if the insurance company approves nothing?

Some do not. Estimate on Demand's pricing page, checked November 17, 2026, says there is no fee when there is no increase, and it bills after the job closes. The American Roof Supplements terms page we read lists a $150 flat fee per supplement but does not say whether it is owed on a denied supplement, so ask any flat-fee company that question in writing before you sign.

Is supplement software cheaper than hiring a supplement company?

On subscription price alone, often yes, but you supply the labor. SupplementSnap listed plans at $99, $199 and $299 a month on November 17, 2026, and OvrScope said its plans start at $199 a month. Software helps your crew document findings and draft supplement language; someone on your team still has to write, submit and follow up on each supplement with the adjuster.

Send every supplement with a measurement you trust.

RoofMetric's Solo plan ($29/month) includes satellite roof measurement with no per-report fee, plus CRM, branded PDF estimates and storm tracking.

Start your free trial →

Sources: Estimate on Demand supplement pricing (checked November 17, 2026); The Estimate Company, what a roofing supplement company charges (checked November 17, 2026); American Roof Supplements terms and conditions (checked November 17, 2026); SupplementSnap (checked November 17, 2026); OvrScope pricing (checked November 17, 2026); RoofMetric pricing.